Steinbauer, M; Beierkuhnlein, C; Arfin Khan, MAS; Harter, D; Irl, S; Jentsch, A; Schweiger, A; Svenning, JC; Dengler, J: How to differentiate facilitation and environmentally driven coexistence, Journal of Vegetation Science, 27, 1071-1079 (2016)
Abstract:

Positive plant-plant interactions (i.e. facilitation) receive increasing attention as a potentially important driver of community assembly. We conducted a systematic literature review indicating broad support for positive effects of potential facilitator species. However, a large majority of the reviewed studies (83% for field studies, 57% for experiment) share a similar risk of misinterpretation as they assess facilitative effects by comparing plots inhabited by a potential facilitator with randomly placed control plots nearby (paired sampling). As the distribution of facilitator species may itself be environmentally driven, species coexistence caused by facilitation cannot exclusively be separated from environmental effects (habitat sharing). Based on simulated plant communities and sampling protocols, we show how non-random coexistence can occur in the absence of facilitation. This is relevant as both the effect of spatial environmental heterogeneity and of facilitation (stress-gradient hypothesis) are expected to increase with environmental harshness. Nevertheless, 58% of facilitation studies neither undertook measures to minimize potential biases in their sampling approaches nor did they acknowledge such limitations in the discussion. Attention to this problem has significantly decreased in recent years. We propose that facilitation studies could be improved (i) by using random sampling for association studies, (ii) by co-analysing environmental factors, or (iii) by experimentally establishing presumed facilitators. Experimental approaches mimicking facilitative plant characteristics can help to identify facilitation mechanisms. Combining approaches and including functional traits of the involved species should further strengthen inference.

Upcoming ...



BayCEER Colloquium:
Th. 2020-01-23 now
Understanding biodiversity dynamics – from human dominated systems to the fossil record
Th. 2020-01-30
BayCEER Mitgliederversammlung
Geographisches Kolloquium:
Tu. 2020-01-28
Adivasis in the Anthropocene - What an Environmental History of Eastern India can tell us about the global agricultural and food crisis
Naturwissenschaftliche Gesellschaft Bayreuth:
Mo. 2020-01-27
Das Insekten- und Vogelsterben vor dem Hintergrund der Natur- und Kulturlandschaftsgeschichte – und wie wir es überwinden können
SFB Mikroplastik:
Mo. 2020-01-27
Wissenschaftskommunikation: Nachhaltigkeit und Mikroplastik
BayCEER Blog
13.01.2020
Why Science Communication?
24.05.2019
Stoichiometric controls of C and N cycling
07.05.2019
Flying halfway across the globe to dig in the dirt – a research stay in Bloomington, USA
07.05.2019
EGU – interesting research and free coffee
RSS Blog as RSS Feed
Weather research site
Luftdruck (356m): 984.5 hPa
Lufttemperatur: -4.8 °C
Niederschlag: 0.0 mm/24h
Sonnenschein: 7 h/d
Wind (Höhe 17m): 2.0 km/h
Wind (Max.): 4.7 km/h
Windrichtung: SO

...more
Globalstrahlung: -1 W/m²
Niederschlag: 0.1 mm/24h
Sonnenschein: 1 h/d
Wind (Höhe 32m): 15.0 km/h

...more
This site makes use of cookies More information